I was a stranger and you invited me in

Although I usually don’t go clearly political around here, it’s happening today; since it’s time-sensitive, I interrupt your regularly schedule programming. Your February Reading Round Up will happen over the weekend, I solemnly promise.

I’ve spent almost a week now pondering the Executive Order issued last week that limits entry to the US by residents of seven Muslim-predominant nations. When I first read about it on Friday, I immediately thought of two former medical students I mentored whose parents immigrated to the US from Iran in the late 1970s under terribly unfavorable conditions. I thought about a young Iraqi who we cared for during my time at Shriners as a fellow. And, of course, I started thinking about many, many immigrant stories of friends, colleagues, and my own family and the impact that blanket policies could have had on many of us.

Of course, over the last week many stories have come to light.  The first one I saw was on Facebook– an Iranian woman with a PhD from Clemson who went home to visit family, then couldn’t get back to her home in South Carolina.  She astutely asked what happens to her car at the airport, to her house filled with her belongings, to her dog? That brought the immediate human cost home to me.

Then there’s the story of this Sudanese physician, training at the Cleveland Clinic, who was in Saudi Arabia on vacation with her family when the Executive Order dropped. She is now suing. She is not alone in this.

For those who don’t know, many foreign medical graduates come from the targeted countries, and many of them are delivering healthcare in areas where we simply can’t get American physicians to work.  Not only does this affect that pipeline, it also may impact their willingness to come here in the future if it becomes easier again.

Most importantly, it appears that the foreign docs we are attracting are the best and the brightest since Medicare patients cared for by IMGs have a better in-hopsital survival rate.

The AAMC and the ACGME have generated thoughtful statements on the impact of this Executive Order on medical education and healthcare delivery. I particularly appreciate the ACGME for acknowledging the associated moral distress around the order; this has been an almost taboo subject, but it really shouldn’t be. This order has real human consequences on scientists, students, and residents; on patients; on families; and on the American healthcare system as it currently functions.

What’s my point here? Simply that this Executive Order appears to have had plenty of unintended consequences.  It wasn’t ready for prime time, and it became clear over the weekend that ICE and DHS weren’t ready for implementation.

And my other point is simply that it’s easy for us not to know all of someone’s story and how they can be impacted by decisions that seem less-than-strategic when you look at all sides. I’m not going to make an argument for wide-open borders, but for us to be able to help people who are trying to help people…well, that seems like the right thing to do.  It also seems, to me, to be relatively apolitical.